Sherrod Brown Has Datacenters Wrong and Populism is Blind to the Grid

Sherrod Brown Has Datacenters Wrong and Populism is Blind to the Grid

Every election cycle needs a villain. This year, populist politicians found a gleaming, high-voltage scapegoat: the artificial intelligence datacenter.

Senator Sherrod Brown is leading that charge in Ohio, framing the massive server farms transforming rural cornfields into power-hungry fortresses as an economic rigged game for ordinary taxpayers. The narrative writes itself. Tech billionaires suck up local electricity, drive up utility bills for working families, and leave behind automated shells while local communities foot the environmental bill. It is the classic grievance script. It plays well on a stump speech. And it is completely, dangerously backwards.

I have spent the past decade watching energy markets, grid operators, and infrastructure finance up close. I have seen municipal councils panic over zoning permits while failing to understand the basic mechanics of how electrons move.

The political establishment wants you to believe datacenters are parasites draining the life out of local power grids. The truth is much more uncomfortable. These facilities are the only entities currently solvent enough, predictable enough, and heavily capitalized enough to force the overdue modernization of an electrical grid that has been rotting from neglect since the Carter administration.

Blaming datacenters for high energy costs is like blaming a heavy rain for a leaky roof. The roof was already broken. The rain just exposed it.

The Lazy Consensus of Grid Populism

The core argument from the populist left and right runs on a simple emotional conveyor belt. Datacenters use an ungodly amount of power. Therefore, your monthly electric bill goes up. Therefore, Big Tech is stealing from the working class.

It sounds airtight until you look at how baseload power actually functions.

Power plants do not turn off just because a factory closes or a town shrinks. Coal, nuclear, and natural gas plants operate best when they run continuously at scale. For decades, utilities struggled with flat or declining industrial demand combined with aging transmission lines. Ratepayers bore the brunt of maintaining a massive, depreciating infrastructure base with a shrinking pool of industrial revenue payers.

When a technology company drops a billion-dollar compute facility into a Rust Belt county, it does not just consume power. It signs long-term, multi-decade power purchase agreements. It builds dedicated substations. It upgrades local transmission lines at private expense.

Critics like to point out that these servers require the output of entire power plants. They fail to mention who pays the capital expenditure for the grid hardening required to deliver that power. It is not the residential ratepayer. It is the enterprise tenant.

If you remove the datacenter from the equation, the fixed costs of maintaining the grid do not vanish. They get redistributed across fewer residential meters. Populist politicians are advocating for policies that would actively accelerate the financial decay of local utilities, disguised as consumer advocacy.

The Real Crisis is Interconnection, Not Consumption

Ask any utility executive what keeps them awake at night, and they will not mention the grid collapsing under the weight of artificial intelligence models. They will talk about the interconnection queue.

Right now, renewable energy projects, industrial expansions, and transmission upgrades are sitting in bureaucratic purgatory for five to seven years just to get permission to plug into the high-voltage transmission system. Regional transmission organizations are drowning in applications they lack the engineering manpower and regulatory clearance to process.

Sherrod Brown wants to treat datacenters as an emergency to be blocked or heavily penalized. That is the exact opposite of what the American economy requires.

Imagine a scenario where a major rust-belt state bans or suffocates new digital infrastructure development out of political panic. The capital does not stay put. It migrates to regions with more pragmatic regulatory frameworks or entirely outside the country, taking the tax base, high-paying engineering jobs, and infrastructural upgrades with it. Meanwhile, the local grid remains ancient, fragile, and vulnerable to weather extremes, supported entirely by residential rate increases.

We do not have a power shortage in the United States. We have a delivery and investment shortage. For thirty years, capital markets refused to fund heavy infrastructure because returns were capped by risk-averse public utility commissions. Now, private capital is practically begging to fund energy infrastructure, grid-scale batteries, nuclear plant restarts, and high-voltage direct current lines.

And politicians want to tax them out of the state because a server rack looks scary in a campaign ad.

The Honest Trade-Offs Nobody Wants to Admit

My contrarian take comes with its own set of brutal truths, and I will not pretend this transition is frictionless.

Datacenter development brings legitimate local friction. They consume water for cooling, though closed-loop systems are rapidly changing that math. They create construction-phase traffic nightmares. Their footprint is massive, and they do not employ thousands of people on a factory floor once construction finishes. A facility worth two billion dollars might run on a skeleton crew of fifty technicians and security personnel.

If you live next to one, your view changes from soybeans to concrete and acoustic fencing. That is a real local cost, and local zoning boards should exact steep community benefit agreements to compensate for it—money for schools, roads, and emergency services.

What local politicians should not do is pretend that halting these projects will lower utility bills. It will do the exact opposite.

When utilities lose massive industrial anchors, the fixed cost of the grid falls squarely on the remaining residential customers. Large commercial and industrial users subsidize residential rates in almost every major power market in the country. Chase them away, and watch what happens to your winter heating bill.

The Uncomfortable Future of American Power

We are standing at the intersection of two undeniable historical forces: the re-industrialization of the American heartland through advanced computing and manufacturing, and a fragile, 20th-century electrical grid that is completely unequipped to handle the load.

Sherrod Brown and his populist peers are fighting yesterday's war. They are treating artificial intelligence like a speculative tech bubble that will blow over if they make it annoying enough to build servers in Ohio.

They are wrong. The compute race is an infrastructural arms race. The nations and states that figure out how to generate cheap, abundant energy and route it efficiently to compute centers will dictate the geopolitical and economic terms of the next century.

You cannot tax your way to energy abundance, and you cannot populist-slogan your way past the laws of thermodynamics.

Stop treating the companies trying to rebuild our power infrastructure as the enemy. Harness them. Tax their capital, force them to co-locate clean generation, make them pay for transmission upgrades, and use their massive financial gravity to fix the grid for everyone else.

Otherwise, keep enjoying your declining tax base, your crumbling transmission lines, and politicians who offer simple answers to complex problems while the rest of the world plugs in and leaves you in the dark.

MS

Mia Smith

Mia Smith is passionate about using journalism as a tool for positive change, focusing on stories that matter to communities and society.